Choosing an Agency
How to Compare SEO and Website Proposals
Compare what each team will do and how you will know whether it helped. Start with the same business goal and baseline for every proposal.
From the Revenue Surge Article Library
Give Each Team the Same Starting Point
Give each team the same service or product, market, business goal and time period. Start with public information or the same approved aggregate totals for qualified inquiries, booked work or orders where available. Flag gaps in tracking and outcomes the records don’t confirm. Ask what each team would check first and what evidence would change its recommendation.
Separate the Work From the Assumptions
List the pages, tasks and deliverables each proposal includes or excludes. Ask who handles copy, design, implementation and approval, and what each team needs before it can start or launch. Compare one time fees, recurring charges, required costs from other providers and any ad spend over the same period. Check whether a lower price reflects a narrower scope.
Agree on the First Progress Review
For each proposal, put the shared goal, first deliverable, person responsible, evidence source, success measure and review date in one worksheet row. Use the same outcome definition, evidence source and reporting period for both proposals. If reliable figures are missing, make establishing a baseline part of the first review. Agree on what evidence would justify changing the plan.
Use the Marketing Decision Worksheet · See How We Define the Work
Ask Who Keeps What if You Change Agencies
Ask whose accounts hold the domain, hosting, website, analytics and ads where applicable, and who has administrator access. Get written terms for what your business owns, which site files, editable creative, reports and data it can export, and which licenses can transfer when the work ends. If you grant Search Console access for an initial SEO audit, limit it to read access.
